eccodes/tools/bufr_compare.c

/*
 * Copyright 2005-2018 ECMWF.
 *
 * This software is licensed under the terms of the Apache Licence Version 2.0
 * which can be obtained at http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0.
 *
 * In applying this licence, ECMWF does not waive the privileges and immunities granted to it by
 * virtue of its status as an intergovernmental organisation nor does it submit to any jurisdiction.
 */

#include "grib_tools.h"

GRIB_INLINE static int grib_inline_strcmp(const char* a,const char* b)
{
    if (*a != *b) return 1;
    while((*a!=0 && *b!=0) &&  *(a) == *(b) ) {a++;b++;}
    return (*a==0 && *b==0) ? 0 : 1;
}

GRIB_INLINE static int grib_inline_rstrcmp(const char* a,const char* b)
{
    char* p=(char*)a;
    char* q=(char*)b;
    while (*p != 0) p++;
    while (*q != 0) q++;
    q--;p--;
    if (*q != *p) return 1;
    while((p!=a && q!=b) &&  *(p) == *(q) ) {p--;q--;}
    return (q==b) ? 0 : 1;
}

typedef double (*compare_double_proc) (double*,double*,double*);

typedef struct grib_error grib_error;
struct grib_error {
    char* key;
    int count;
    grib_error* next;
};

grib_error* error_summary;

compare_double_proc compare_double;
double global_tolerance=0;
int packingCompare=0;
grib_string_list* blacklist=0;
grib_string_list* keys_list = NULL; /* Used to determine rank of key */
int isLeafKey = 0; /* 0 if key is top-level, 1 if key has no children attributes */
int compareAbsolute=1;

static int compare_handles(grib_handle* handle1, grib_handle* handle2, grib_runtime_options* options);
static int compare_values(grib_runtime_options* options, grib_handle* handle1, grib_handle *handle2, const char *name, int type);
static int compare_attributes(grib_handle* handle1, grib_handle* handle2, grib_runtime_options* options,
        grib_accessor* a, const char* prefix, int* err);
static int compare_attribute(grib_handle* handle1, grib_handle* handle2, grib_runtime_options* options,
        grib_accessor* a, const char* prefix, int* err);

int error=0;
int count=0;
int lastPrint=0;
int force=0;

/* ECC-651: Boolean 'two_way' set to 1 when '-2' option used */
int two_way=0;
/* Boolean 'handles_swapped' relevant in 'two_way' mode:
 *  0 means: h1 is first file,  h2 is second file
 *  1 means: h1 is second file, h2 is first file
 */
int handles_swapped=0;

double maxAbsoluteError = 1e-19;
int onlyListed=1;
int headerMode=0;
int morein1=0;
int morein2=0;
int listFromCommandLine;
int verbose=0;
int tolerance_factor=1;
static int write_error=0;

/* Create the list of keys (global variable keys_list) */
static void new_keys_list()
{
    grib_context* c = grib_context_get_default();
    keys_list=(grib_string_list*)grib_context_malloc_clear(c, sizeof(grib_string_list));
    if (!keys_list) {
        fprintf(stderr, "Failed to allocate memory for keys list");
        exit(1);
    }
}

/* Free the keys list (global variable keys_list) */
static void release_keys_list()
{
    grib_string_list* next=keys_list;
    grib_string_list* cur=keys_list;
    grib_context* c = grib_context_get_default();
    while(next) {
        cur=next;
        next=next->next;
        grib_context_free(c,cur->value);
        grib_context_free(c,cur);
    }
}

GRIB_INLINE static double compare_double_absolute(double *a,double *b,double *err)
{
    double ret=0;
    double d=fabs(*a-*b);
    if (d > *err) {
        ret=d;
    }
    return ret;
    /* return fabs(*a-*b) > *err ? fabs(*a-*b) : 0; */
}

static int write_count=0;

static void write_message(grib_handle* h,const char* str)
{
    const void *m; size_t s;
    char fname[1024]={0,};
    FILE* fh;

    grib_get_message(h,&m,&s);
    sprintf(fname,"%s_%d.bufr",str,write_count);

    fh= fopen(fname,"w");
    if(!fh) {
        grib_context_log(h->context,(GRIB_LOG_ERROR)|(GRIB_LOG_PERROR),
                "Error opening %s",fname);
        exit(GRIB_IO_PROBLEM);
    }

    if(fwrite(m,1,s,fh) != s) {
        grib_context_log(h->context,(GRIB_LOG_ERROR)|(GRIB_LOG_PERROR),
                "Error writing to %s",fname);
        exit(GRIB_IO_PROBLEM);
    }

    fclose(fh);
}

static void write_messages(grib_handle* handle1, grib_handle* handle2)
{
    if (!write_error) return;
    write_count++;

    write_message(handle1,"error1");
    write_message(handle2,"error2");
}

static double compare_double_relative(double *a,double *b,double *err)
{
    double relativeError;

    if(fabs(*a) <= maxAbsoluteError || fabs(*b) <= maxAbsoluteError)
        relativeError = fabs(*a-*b);
    else if (fabs(*b) > fabs(*a))
        relativeError = fabs((*a-*b) / *b);
    else
        relativeError = fabs((*a-*b) / *a);

    return relativeError > *err ? relativeError : 0;
}

static int blacklisted(const char* name)
{
    grib_string_list* b=blacklist;
    while (b) {
        Assert(b->value);
        if (!strcmp(name,b->value))
            return 1;
        b=b->next;
    }
    return 0;
}

static double relative_error(double a,double b,double err)
{
    double relativeError;

    if(fabs(a) <= maxAbsoluteError || fabs(b) <= maxAbsoluteError)
        relativeError = fabs(a-b);
    else if (fabs(b) > fabs(a))
        relativeError = fabs((a-b) / b);
    else
        relativeError = fabs((a-b) / a);

    return relativeError ;
}

grib_option grib_options[]={
    /*  {id, args, help}, on, command_line, value*/
    /*{"r",0,"Compare files in which the messages are not in the same order. This option is time expensive.\n",0,1,0},*/
    {"b:",0,0,0,1,0},
    {"d",0,"Write different messages on files.\n",0,1,0},
    {"2",0,"Enable two-way comparison.\n",0,1,0},
    {"T:",0,0,1,0,"B"},
    {"c:",0,0,0,1,0},
    {"S:","start","First field to be processed.\n",0,1,0},
    {"E:","end","Last field to be processed.\n",0,1,0},
    {"a",0,"-c option modifier. The keys listed with the option -c will be added to the list of keys compared without -c.\n"
                ,0,1,0},
    {"H",0,"Compare only message headers. Bit-by-bit compare on. Incompatible with -c option.\n",0,1,0},
    {"R:",0,0,0,1,0},
    {"A:",0,0,0,1,0},
/*    {"P",0,"Compare data values using the packing error as tolerance.\n",0,1,0},*/
    {"t:","factor","Compare data values using factor multiplied by the tolerance specified in options -P -R -A.\n",0,1,0},
    {"w:",0,0,0,1,0},
    {"f",0,0,0,1,0},
    {"F",0,0,1,0,0},
    {"q",0,0,1,0,0},
    {"M",0,0,1,0,0},
    {"I",0,0,1,0,0},
    {"V",0,0,0,1,0},
    {"7",0,0,0,1,0},
    {"v",0,0,0,1,0}
};

grib_handle* global_handle=NULL;
int counter=0;
int start=-1;
int end=-1;

const char* grib_tool_description=
    "Compare BUFR messages contained in two files."
    "\n\tIf some differences are found it fails returning an error code."
    "\n\tFloating-point values are compared exactly by default, different tolerance can be defined see -P -A -R."
    "\n\tDefault behaviour: absolute error=0, bit-by-bit compare, same order in files.";

const char* grib_tool_name="bufr_compare";
const char* grib_tool_usage="[options] bufr_file1 bufr_file2";

int grib_options_count=sizeof(grib_options)/sizeof(grib_option);

int main(int argc, char *argv[])
{
    return grib_tool(argc,argv);
}

int grib_tool_before_getopt(grib_runtime_options* options)
{
    return 0;
}

int grib_tool_init(grib_runtime_options* options)
{
    int ret=0,i;
    int nfiles=1;
    char orderby[]="md5Headers";
    grib_context* context=grib_context_get_default();

    options->strict=1;
    if (grib_options_on("S:"))
        start=atoi(grib_options_get_option("S:"));

    if (grib_options_on("E:"))
        end=atoi(grib_options_get_option("E:"));

    if (grib_options_on("f")) force=1;
    else force=0;

    if (grib_options_on("2")) two_way=1;
    else two_way=0;

    if (grib_options_on("d")) write_error=1;
    else write_error=0;

    verbose = grib_options_on("v");

    listFromCommandLine=0;
    if (grib_options_on("c:") || grib_options_on("e"))
        listFromCommandLine=1;

    if (grib_options_on("a")) onlyListed=0;
    else onlyListed=1;

    if (grib_options_on("H")) headerMode=1;
    else headerMode=0;

    if (grib_options_on("H") && grib_options_on("c:")) {
        fprintf(stderr,"Error: -H and -c options are incompatible. Choose one of the two please.\n");
        exit(1);
    }
    if (grib_options_on("a") && !grib_options_on("c:")) {
        fprintf(stderr,"Error: -a option requires -c option. Please define a list of keys with the -c option.\n");
        exit(1);
    }

    if (grib_options_on("b:")) {
        grib_string_list *next=0;
        int ii=0;
        blacklist=(grib_string_list*)grib_context_malloc_clear(context,sizeof(grib_string_list));
        blacklist->value=grib_context_strdup(context,options->set_values[0].name);
        next=blacklist;
        for (ii=1;ii<options->set_values_count;ii++) {
            next->next=(grib_string_list*)grib_context_malloc_clear(context,sizeof(grib_string_list));
            next->next->value=grib_context_strdup(context,options->set_values[ii].name);
            next=next->next;
        }
        context->blacklist=blacklist;
    }

    if (grib_options_on("r")) {
        char* filename[1];
        filename[0]=options->infile_extra->name;
        options->random=1;
        options->orderby=strdup(orderby);
        options->idx=grib_fieldset_new_from_files(context,filename,
                nfiles,0,0,0,orderby,&ret);
        if (ret) {
            fprintf(stderr,"unable to create index for input file %s (%s)",
                    options->infile_extra->name, grib_get_error_message(ret));
            exit(ret);
        }
    } else {
        options->random=0;
        options->infile_extra->file=fopen(options->infile_extra->name,"r");

        if (!options->infile_extra->file) {
            perror(options->infile_extra->name);
            exit(1);
        }
    }

    global_tolerance=0;
    compare_double= &compare_double_absolute;
    if (grib_options_on("R:")) {
        global_tolerance=0;
        for (i=0;i<options->tolerance_count;i++) {
            if (!strcmp((options->tolerance[i]).name,"all")) {
                global_tolerance=(options->tolerance[i]).double_value;
                break;
            }
            if (!strcmp((options->tolerance[i]).name,"global")) {
                global_tolerance=(options->tolerance[i]).double_value;
                break;
            }
        }
        compare_double= &compare_double_relative;
        compareAbsolute=0;
    }
    if (grib_options_on("A:")){
        if (grib_options_on("R:")) {
            maxAbsoluteError = atof(grib_options_get_option("A:"));
        } else {
            compare_double= &compare_double_absolute;
            global_tolerance = atof(grib_options_get_option("A:"));
        }
    }
    if (grib_options_on("P")) {
        packingCompare=1;
        compare_double= &compare_double_absolute;
    }

    if (grib_options_on("t:"))
        tolerance_factor=atof(grib_options_get_option("t:"));

    if (grib_options_on("R:")) {
        char* sarg=grib_options_get_option("R:");
        options->tolerance_count=MAX_KEYS;
        ret=parse_keyval_string(grib_tool_name, sarg,1,GRIB_TYPE_DOUBLE,options->tolerance,&(options->tolerance_count));
        if (ret == GRIB_INVALID_ARGUMENT) {
            usage();
            exit(1);
        }
    }

    {
        /* Check for 2nd file being a directory. If so, we assume user is comparing to a file */
        /* with the same name as first file in that directory */
        struct stat s;
        grib_tools_file* infile = options->infile; /* the 2nd file in comparison */
        if (infile) {
            int stat_val = stat(infile->name, &s);
            if ( stat_val == 0 && S_ISDIR(s.st_mode)) {
                /* Take the filename of the 1st file and append to dir */
                char bufr[2048] = {0,};
                /* options->infile_extra->name is the 1st file */
                sprintf(bufr, "%s%c%s",
                        infile->name,
                        get_dir_separator_char(),
                        extract_filename(options->infile_extra->name));
                infile->name = strdup(bufr);
            }
        }
    }

    /* Turn off GRIB multi-field support mode. Not relevant for BUFR */
    grib_multi_support_off(grib_context_get_default());

    return 0;
}

int grib_tool_new_filename_action(grib_runtime_options* options,const char* file)
{
    return 0;
}

int grib_tool_new_file_action(grib_runtime_options* options,grib_tools_file* file)
{
    exit_if_input_is_directory(grib_tool_name, file->name);
    return 0;
}

static void printInfo(grib_handle* h)
{
    printf("== %d == DIFFERENCE == ",count);
    lastPrint=count;
}

static void print_index_key_values(grib_index* index,int icounter,const char* error_message)
{
    grib_index_key* keys=index->keys;
    printf("== %d == ",icounter);
    if (error_message) printf("%s == ",error_message);
    while (keys) {
        printf("%s=%s ",keys->name,keys->value);
        keys=keys->next;
    }
    printf("\n");
}

static grib_handle* grib_handle_new_from_file_x(
        grib_context* c,FILE* f,int mode,int headers_only,int *err)
{
    return codes_handle_new_from_file(c,f,PRODUCT_BUFR,err);
}

int grib_tool_new_handle_action(grib_runtime_options* options, grib_handle* h)
{
    int err=0;
    count++;

    if (options->through_index) {
        grib_index* idx1=options->index1;
        verbose=0;
        counter++;

        if ( start>0 && counter < start ) return 0;
        if ( end>0 && counter > end ) {
            options->stop=1;
            return 0;
        }

        grib_index_search_same(idx1,h);
        global_handle=codes_new_from_index(idx1,CODES_BUFR,&err);
        if (options->verbose) {
            off_t offset=0;
            char* filename=grib_get_field_file(options->index2,&offset);
            printf("file1=\"%s\" ",filename);
            filename=grib_get_field_file(options->index1,&offset);
            printf("file2=\"%s\" \n",filename);
            print_index_key_values(options->index1,counter,NULL);
        }

        if (!global_handle) {
            if (!options->verbose)
                print_index_key_values(idx1,counter,"NOT FOUND ");
        }

        if (!global_handle || err!= GRIB_SUCCESS ) {
            morein1++;
            if (global_handle) grib_handle_delete(global_handle);
            return 0;
        }

        if(compare_handles(h,global_handle,options)) {
            error++;
            if (!force) exit(1);
        }

        grib_handle_delete(global_handle);

        return 0;

    } else if (options->random)
        global_handle = grib_fieldset_next_handle(options->idx,&err);
    else
        global_handle=grib_handle_new_from_file_x(h->context,options->infile_extra->file,options->mode,0,&err);

    if (!global_handle || err!= GRIB_SUCCESS ) {
        morein2++;
        if (global_handle) grib_handle_delete(global_handle);
        return 0;
    }

    if(compare_handles(global_handle,h,options)) {
        error++;
        if (!two_way) {
            /* If two_way mode: Don't exit yet. Show further differences */
            if (!force) exit(1);
        }
    }
    if (two_way) {
        /* ECC-651 and ECC-431 */
        handles_swapped = 1;
        if (verbose) printf("  Swapping handles (two-way mode)\n");
        if(compare_handles(h, global_handle, options)) {
            error++;
            if (!force) exit(1);
        } else {
            if (error) {
                /* Error from first pass */
                if (!force) exit(1);
            }
        }
    }

    grib_handle_delete(global_handle);

    return 0;
}

int grib_tool_skip_handle(grib_runtime_options* options, grib_handle* h)
{
    int err=0;
    if (!options->through_index && !options->random)  {
        global_handle=grib_handle_new_from_file(h->context,options->infile_extra->file,&err);

        if (!global_handle || err!= GRIB_SUCCESS)
            morein2++;

        grib_handle_delete(global_handle);
    }

    grib_handle_delete(h);
    count++;

    return 0;
}

void grib_tool_print_key_values(grib_runtime_options* options,grib_handle* h)
{
    grib_print_key_values(options,h);
}

int grib_tool_finalise_action(grib_runtime_options* options)
{
    grib_error* e = error_summary;
    int err=0;
    grib_context* c=grib_context_get_default();
    error += morein1+morein2;

    /*if (grib_options_on("w:")) return 0;*/

    if (error) {
        printf("\n## ERRORS SUMMARY #######\n");
    }
    while ((global_handle=grib_handle_new_from_file(c,options->infile_extra->file,&err))) {
        morein1++;
        if (global_handle) grib_handle_delete(global_handle);
    }
    if (morein1>0) {
        printf("##\n## Different number of messages \n");
        printf("## %d more messages in %s than in %s\n",morein1,
                options->infile_extra->name,options->infile->name);
    }

    if (morein2>0) {
        printf("##\n## Different number of messages \n");
        printf("## %d more messages in %s than in %s\n",morein2,
                options->infile->name,options->infile_extra->name);
    }

    if (error) {
        printf("##\n## Summary of different key values \n");
        while (e) {
            printf ("## %s ( %d different )\n",e->key,e->count);
            e=e->next;
        }

        printf("##\n## %d different messages out of %d\n\n",error,count);
    }
    if (options->through_index) {
        grib_index_delete(options->index1);
        grib_index_delete(options->index2);
    }
    release_keys_list();
    if (error != 0) exit(1);
    return 0;
}

static void save_error(grib_context* c,const char* key)
{
    grib_error* e=0;
    grib_error* next=0;
    int saved=0;

    if (!error_summary) {
        error_summary=(grib_error*)grib_context_malloc_clear(c,sizeof(grib_error));
        error_summary->count=1;
        error_summary->key=grib_context_strdup(c,key);
        return;
    }

    e=error_summary;
    next=e;

    while (next) {
        if (!strcmp(next->key,key)) {
            next->count++;
            saved=1;
            break;
        }
        e=next;
        next=next->next;
    }

    if (!saved) {
        e->next=(grib_error*)grib_context_malloc_clear(c,sizeof(grib_error));
        e->next->count=1;
        e->next->key=grib_context_strdup(c,key);
    }
}

static char* double_as_string(grib_context* c, double v)
{
    char* sval=(char*)grib_context_malloc_clear(c, sizeof(char)*40);
    if (v == GRIB_MISSING_DOUBLE) sprintf(sval,"MISSING");
    else                          sprintf(sval,"%.20e",v);
    return sval;
}

/* Return the part of the key name without the '#rank#' part */
static char* get_keyname_without_rank(const char* name)
{
    char* p=(char*)name;
    char* end=p;
    char* ret=NULL;

    if (*p=='#') {
        strtol(++p,&end,10);
        if ( *end != '#') {
            DebugAssert(!"Badly formed rank in key");
        } else {
            /* Take everything after 2nd '#' */
            grib_context* c=grib_context_get_default();
            end++;
            ret=grib_context_strdup(c,end);
        }
    }
    return ret;
}

static int compare_values(grib_runtime_options* options, grib_handle* handle1, grib_handle *handle2, const char *name, int type)
{
    size_t len1 = 0;
    size_t len2 = 0;
    int err=0,i=0;
    int err1;
    int err2;
    int type1,type2;
    int countdiff;
    int isangle=0;
    int isMissing1=0,isMissing2=0;

    char *sval1 = NULL,*sval2 = NULL;
    unsigned char *uval1 = NULL,*uval2 = NULL;
    double *dval1 = NULL, *dval2 = NULL;
    long *lval1 = NULL, *lval2 = NULL;
    double maxdiff=0;
    double packingError1=0,packingError2=0;
    double value_tolerance=0;
    grib_context* c=handle1->context;
    const char* first_str = (handles_swapped==0? "1st" : "2nd");
    const char* second_str = (handles_swapped==0? "2nd" : "1st");

    type1=type;
    type2=type;
    if (verbose && !handles_swapped) printf("  comparing %s",name);

    if( type1==GRIB_TYPE_UNDEFINED && (err = grib_get_native_type(handle1,name,&type1)) != GRIB_SUCCESS)
    {
        printInfo(handle1);
        printf("Oops... cannot get type of [%s] in %s field: %s\n",name, first_str, grib_get_error_message(err));
        save_error(c,name);
        return err;
    }

    if(type2==GRIB_TYPE_UNDEFINED && (err = grib_get_native_type(handle2,name,&type2)) != GRIB_SUCCESS)
    {
        if(err == GRIB_NOT_FOUND)
        {
            printInfo(handle1);
            printf("[%s] not found in %s field\n",name, second_str);
            save_error(c,name);
            return err;
        }
        printInfo(handle1);
        printf("Oops... cannot get type of [%s] in %s field: %s\n",name, second_str, grib_get_error_message(err));
        save_error(c,name);
        return err;
    }

    /* if(type1 != type2) {
         printInfo(handle1);
         printf("Warning, [%s] has different types: 1st field: [%s], 2nd field: [%s]\n",
           name,grib_get_type_name(type1),grib_get_type_name(type2));
         return GRIB_TYPE_MISMATCH;
    } */

    if(type1 == GRIB_TYPE_LABEL)
        return err;

    if(type1 == GRIB_TYPE_SECTION)
        return err;

    if((err = grib_get_size(handle1,name,&len1)) != GRIB_SUCCESS)
    {
        printInfo(handle1);
        printf("Oops... cannot get size of [%s] in %s field: %s\n",name, first_str, grib_get_error_message(err));
        save_error(c,name);
        return err;
    }

    if((err = grib_get_size(handle2,name,&len2)) != GRIB_SUCCESS)
    {
        if(err == GRIB_NOT_FOUND)
        {
            printInfo(handle1);
            printf("[%s] not found in %s field\n",name,second_str);
            save_error(c,name);
            return err;
        }

        printInfo(handle1);
        printf("Oops... cannot get size of [%s] in %s field: %s\n",name, second_str, grib_get_error_message(err));
        save_error(c,name);
        return err;
    }
    
    if (handles_swapped) {
        /* Comparing a second time with handles swapped. Do not compare keys common to both handles */
        return GRIB_SUCCESS;
    }
    /* if(len1 != len2 && type1 != GRIB_TYPE_STRING) {
          printInfo(handle1);
          printf("[%s] has different size: 1st field: %ld, 2nd field: %ld\n",name,(long)len1,(long)len2);
          save_error(c,name);
          return GRIB_COUNT_MISMATCH;
        } */

    if (options->mode != MODE_BUFR) {
        /* TODO: Ignore missing values for keys in BUFR. Not yet implemented */
        isMissing1= ( (grib_is_missing(handle1,name,&err1)==1) && (err1 == 0) ) ? 1 : 0;
        isMissing2= ( (grib_is_missing(handle2,name,&err2)==1) && (err2 == 0) ) ? 1 : 0;
    }

    if ((isMissing1==1) && (isMissing2==1)) {
        if (verbose) printf(" is set to missing in both fields\n");
        return GRIB_SUCCESS;
    }

    if (isMissing1==1) {
        if (verbose) printf(" is set to missing in %s field\n", first_str);
        printInfo(handle1);
        printf("%s is set to missing in %s field is not missing in %s field\n",name,first_str,second_str);
        err1 = GRIB_VALUE_MISMATCH;
        save_error(c,name);
        return GRIB_VALUE_MISMATCH;
    }

    if (isMissing2==1) {
        if (verbose) printf(" is set to missing in %s field\n", first_str);
        printInfo(handle1);
        printf("%s is set to missing in %s field is not missing in %s field\n",name, second_str, first_str);
        err1 = GRIB_VALUE_MISMATCH;
        save_error(c,name);
        return GRIB_VALUE_MISMATCH;
    }

    switch(type1)
    {
    case GRIB_TYPE_STRING:
        if (verbose) printf(" as string\n");
        /* See ECC-710: It is very slow getting the key length this way */
        /*grib_get_string_length(handle1,name,&len1);*/
        /*grib_get_string_length(handle2,name,&len2);*/
        len1 = len2 = 4096; /* Significantly faster to use an upper bound */
        sval1 = (char*)grib_context_malloc(handle1->context,len1*sizeof(char));
        sval2 = (char*)grib_context_malloc(handle2->context,len2*sizeof(char));

        if((err1 = grib_get_string(handle1,name,sval1,&len1)) != GRIB_SUCCESS)
        {
            printInfo(handle1);
            printf("Oops... cannot get string value of [%s] in %s field: %s\n",
                    name, first_str, grib_get_error_message(err1));
            save_error(c,name);
        }

        if((err2 = grib_get_string(handle2,name,sval2,&len2)) != GRIB_SUCCESS)
        {
            printInfo(handle1);
            printf("Oops... cannot get string value of [%s] in %s field: %s\n",
                    name, second_str, grib_get_error_message(err2));
            save_error(c,name);
        }

        if(err1 == GRIB_SUCCESS && err2 == GRIB_SUCCESS)
        {
            if(grib_inline_strcmp(sval1,sval2) != 0)
            {
                /* Check if strings are 'missing'.
                 * Note: one string could have all its bits=1 and the other empty */
                int equal = 0;
                grib_accessor* a1 = grib_find_accessor(handle1, name);
                grib_accessor* a2 = grib_find_accessor(handle2, name);
                int is_miss_1 = grib_is_missing_string(a1, (unsigned char *)sval1, len1);
                int is_miss_2 = grib_is_missing_string(a2, (unsigned char *)sval2, len2);
                if ( is_miss_1 && is_miss_2 ) {
                    equal = 1;
                }
                if (!equal) {
                    printInfo(handle1);
                    printf("string [%s]: [%s] != [%s]\n", name, sval1, sval2);
                    err1 = GRIB_VALUE_MISMATCH;
                    save_error(c,name);
                }
            }
        }

        grib_context_free(handle1->context,sval1);
        grib_context_free(handle2->context,sval2);

        if(err1) return err1;
        if(err2) return err2;

        break;

    case GRIB_TYPE_LONG:
        if (verbose) printf(" as long\n");

        lval1 = (long*)grib_context_malloc(handle1->context,len1*sizeof(long));
        lval2 = (long*)grib_context_malloc(handle2->context,len2*sizeof(long));

        if((err1 = grib_get_long_array(handle1,name,lval1,&len1)) != GRIB_SUCCESS)
        {
            printInfo(handle1);
            printf("Oops... cannot get long value of [%s] in %s field: %s\n",
                    name, first_str, grib_get_error_message(err1));
            save_error(c,name);
        }

        if((err2 = grib_get_long_array(handle2,name,lval2,&len2)) != GRIB_SUCCESS)
        {
            printInfo(handle1);
            printf("Oops... cannot get long value of [%s] in %s field: %s\n",
                    name,second_str,grib_get_error_message(err2));
            save_error(c,name);
        }

        if(err1 == GRIB_SUCCESS && err2 == GRIB_SUCCESS && len1!=len2)
        {
            printInfo(handle1);
            printf("Different size for \"%s\"  [%ld]  [%ld]\n",name,(long)len1,(long)len2);
            err1=GRIB_INTERNAL_ERROR;
            save_error(c,name);
        }
        if(err1 == GRIB_SUCCESS && err2 == GRIB_SUCCESS && len1==len2)
        {
            int ii;
            countdiff=0;
            for(ii = 0; ii < len1; ii++)
                if(lval1[ii] != lval2[ii])  countdiff++;

            if (countdiff) {
                printInfo(handle1);
                save_error(c,name);
                err1 = GRIB_VALUE_MISMATCH;
                if(len1 == 1)
                    printf("long [%s]: [%ld] != [%ld]\n", name, *lval1, *lval2);
                else
                    printf("long [%s] %d out of %ld different\n", name, countdiff, (long)len1);
            }
        }

        grib_context_free(handle1->context,lval1);
        grib_context_free(handle2->context,lval2);

        if(err1) return err1;
        if(err2) return err2;
        break;

    case GRIB_TYPE_DOUBLE:
        if (verbose) printf(" as double\n");
        dval1 = (double*)grib_context_malloc(handle1->context,len1*sizeof(double));
        dval2 = (double*)grib_context_malloc(handle2->context,len2*sizeof(double));

        isangle=0;
        value_tolerance=global_tolerance;
        if (!grib_inline_strcmp(name,"packedValues") || !grib_inline_strcmp(name,"values")
                || !grib_inline_strcmp(name,"codedValues")) {
            packingError1=0;
            packingError2=0;
            err1=grib_get_double(handle1,"packingError",&packingError1);
            err2=grib_get_double(handle2,"packingError",&packingError2);
            if (packingCompare)
                value_tolerance = packingError1 > packingError2 ? packingError1 : packingError2;
        } else if (!grib_inline_strcmp(name,"unpackedValues") ) {
            packingError1=0;
            packingError2=0;
            err1=grib_get_double(handle1,"unpackedError",&packingError1);
            err2=grib_get_double(handle2,"unpackedError",&packingError2);
            if (packingCompare)
                value_tolerance = packingError1 > packingError2 ? packingError1 : packingError2;
        } else if ( !grib_inline_rstrcmp(name,"InDegrees")) {
            packingError1=0.0005;
            packingError2=0.0005;
            isangle=1;
            value_tolerance = packingError1 > packingError2 ? packingError1 : packingError2;
        } else if (!grib_inline_strcmp(name,"referenceValue") ) {
            packingError1=0;
            packingError2=0;
            err1=grib_get_double(handle1,"referenceValueError",&packingError1);
            err2=grib_get_double(handle2,"referenceValueError",&packingError2);
            value_tolerance = packingError1 > packingError2 ? packingError1 : packingError2;
        }

        if (!compareAbsolute) {
            int all_specified = 0; /* =1 if relative comparison with "all" specified */
            for (i=0;i<options->tolerance_count;i++) {
                if (!strcmp((options->tolerance[i]).name, "all")) {
                    all_specified = 1;
                    value_tolerance=(options->tolerance[i]).double_value;
                    break;
                }
            }
            if (!all_specified) {
                char* basename = NULL;
                for (i=0;i<options->tolerance_count;i++) {
                    if ( strcmp( (options->tolerance[i]).name, name)==0 ) {
                        value_tolerance=(options->tolerance[i]).double_value;
                        break;
                    } else {
                        /* Check if the key without its rank has a relative tolerance */
                        basename = get_keyname_without_rank(name);
                        if ( basename && strcmp( (options->tolerance[i]).name, basename)==0 ) {
                            value_tolerance=(options->tolerance[i]).double_value;
                            break;
                        }
                    }
                }
                if (basename) grib_context_free(handle1->context, basename);
            }
        }

        if((err1 = grib_get_double_array(handle1,name,dval1,&len1)) != GRIB_SUCCESS)
        {
            printInfo(handle1);
            printf("Oops... cannot get double value of [%s] in %s field: %s\n",
                    name, first_str, grib_get_error_message(err1));
            save_error(c,name);
        }

        if((err2 = grib_get_double_array(handle2,name,dval2,&len2)) != GRIB_SUCCESS)
        {
            printInfo(handle1);
            printf("Oops... cannot get double value of [%s] in %s field: %s\n",
                    name,second_str,grib_get_error_message(err2));
            save_error(c,name);
        }

        if(err1 == GRIB_SUCCESS && err2 == GRIB_SUCCESS && len1!=len2)
        {
            printInfo(handle1);
            printf("Different size for \"%s\"  [%ld]  [%ld]\n",name,(long)len1,(long)len2);
            save_error(c,name);
        }
        if(err1 == GRIB_SUCCESS && err2 == GRIB_SUCCESS && len1==len2)
        {
            int imaxdiff;
            double diff;
            double *pv1,*pv2,dnew1,dnew2;
            maxdiff=0;
            imaxdiff=0;
            countdiff=0;
            pv1=dval1;
            pv2=dval2;
            if (isangle) {
                dnew1=*dval1; dnew2=*dval2;
                pv1=&dnew1; pv2=&dnew2;
                if (*dval1 < 0 ) dnew1 += 360.0 ;
                if (*dval2 < 0 ) dnew2 += 360.0 ;
                if (*dval1 > 360 ) dnew1 -= 360.0 ;
                if (*dval2 > 360 ) dnew2 -= 360.0 ;
            }
            value_tolerance*=tolerance_factor;
            if (verbose) printf("  (%d values) tolerance=%g\n",(int)len1,value_tolerance);
            for(i = 0; i < len1; i++) {
                if((diff=compare_double(pv1++,pv2++,&value_tolerance))!=0) {
                    countdiff++;
                    if (maxdiff < diff) {maxdiff=diff;imaxdiff=i;}
                    err1 = GRIB_VALUE_MISMATCH;
                }
            }

            if (countdiff) {
                printInfo(handle1);
                save_error(c,name);
                if (len1>1) {
                    printf("double [%s]: %d out of %ld different\n",name,countdiff,(long)len1);
                    if (dval1[imaxdiff] != GRIB_MISSING_DOUBLE && dval2[imaxdiff] != GRIB_MISSING_DOUBLE) {
                        if (compareAbsolute) printf(" max");
                        printf(" absolute diff. = %.16e,",fabs(dval1[imaxdiff]-dval2[imaxdiff]));
                        if (!compareAbsolute) printf(" max");
                        printf(" relative diff. = %g",relative_error(dval1[imaxdiff],dval2[imaxdiff],value_tolerance));
                        printf("\n\tmax diff. element %d: %.20e %.20e",
                                imaxdiff,dval1[imaxdiff],dval2[imaxdiff]);
                        printf("\n\ttolerance=%.16e",value_tolerance);
                    } else {
                        /* One or both values are missing */
                        char* svalA = double_as_string(c, dval1[imaxdiff]);
                        char* svalB = double_as_string(c, dval2[imaxdiff]);
                        printf("\tdiff. element %d: %s %s", imaxdiff, svalA, svalB);
                        grib_context_free(c,svalA);
                        grib_context_free(c,svalB);
                    }
                    if (packingError2!=0 || packingError1!=0)
                        printf(" packingError: [%g] [%g]",packingError1,packingError2);

                    if (!grib_inline_strcmp(name,"packedValues") || !grib_inline_strcmp(name,"values")
                            || !grib_inline_strcmp(name,"codedValues")) {
                        double max1,min1,max2,min2;
                        grib_get_double(handle1,"max",&max1);
                        grib_get_double(handle1,"min",&min1);
                        grib_get_double(handle2,"max",&max2);
                        grib_get_double(handle2,"min",&min2);
                        printf("\n\tvalues max= [%g]  [%g]         min= [%g] [%g]",max1,max2,min1,min2);
                    }
                    printf("\n");
                } else {
                    if (dval1[0] != GRIB_MISSING_DOUBLE && dval2[0] != GRIB_MISSING_DOUBLE) {
                        printf("double [%s]: [%.20e] != [%.20e]\n", name, dval1[0], dval2[0]);
                        printf("\tabsolute diff. = %g,",fabs(dval1[0]-dval2[0]));
                        printf(" relative diff. = %g\n",relative_error(dval1[0],dval2[0],value_tolerance));
                        printf("\ttolerance=%g\n",value_tolerance);
                    } else {
                        /* One or both values are missing */
                        char* svalA = double_as_string(c, dval1[0]);
                        char* svalB = double_as_string(c, dval2[0]);
                        printf("double [%s]: [%s] != [%s]\n", name, svalA, svalB);
                        grib_context_free(c,svalA);
                        grib_context_free(c,svalB);
                    }
                }
            }
        }

        grib_context_free(handle1->context,dval1);
        grib_context_free(handle2->context,dval2);

        if(err1) return err1;
        if(err2) return err2;
        break;

    case GRIB_TYPE_BYTES:
        if (verbose) printf(" as bytes\n");
        if (options->mode==MODE_BUFR) return 0;
        if (len1<2) len1=512;
        if (len2<2) len2=512;
        uval1 = (unsigned char*)grib_context_malloc(handle1->context,len1*sizeof(unsigned char));
        uval2 = (unsigned char*)grib_context_malloc(handle2->context,len2*sizeof(unsigned char));

        if((err1 = grib_get_bytes(handle1,name,uval1,&len1)) != GRIB_SUCCESS)
        {
            printInfo(handle1);
            save_error(c,name);
            printf("Oops... cannot get bytes value of [%s] in %s field: %s\n",
                    name,first_str,grib_get_error_message(err1));
        }

        if((err2 = grib_get_bytes(handle2,name,uval2,&len2)) != GRIB_SUCCESS)
        {
            printInfo(handle1);
            save_error(c,name);
            printf("Oops... cannot get bytes value of [%s] in %s field: %s\n",
                    name,second_str,grib_get_error_message(err2));
        }

        if(err1 == GRIB_SUCCESS && err2 == GRIB_SUCCESS)
        {
            if(memcmp(uval1,uval2,len1) != 0)
            {
                for(i = 0; i < len1; i++) {
                    if(uval1[i] != uval2[i])
                    {
                        printInfo(handle1);
                        save_error(c,name);
                        if(len1 == 1)
                            printf("[%s] byte values are different: [%02x] and [%02x]\n",
                                    name,uval1[i],uval2[i]);
                        else
                            printf("[%s] byte value %d of %ld are different: [%02x] and [%02x]\n",
                                    name,i,(long)len1,uval1[i],uval2[i]);

                        err1 = GRIB_VALUE_MISMATCH;
                        break;
                    }
                }
                err1 = GRIB_VALUE_MISMATCH;
            }
        }

        grib_context_free(handle1->context,uval1);
        grib_context_free(handle2->context,uval2);

        if(err1) return err1;
        if(err2) return err2;
        break;

    case GRIB_TYPE_LABEL:
        if (verbose) printf(" as label\n");
        break;

    default:
        if (verbose) printf("\n");
        printInfo(handle1);
        save_error(c,name);
        printf("Cannot compare [%s], unsupported type %d\n",name,type1);
        return GRIB_UNABLE_TO_COMPARE_ACCESSORS;
        break;
    }

    return GRIB_SUCCESS;
}

static int compare_attributes(grib_handle* handle1, grib_handle* handle2, grib_runtime_options* options,
        grib_accessor* a, const char* prefix, int* err)
{
    int i=0, ret=0;
    while (i < MAX_ACCESSOR_ATTRIBUTES && a->attributes[i])
    {
        /*long native_type = 0;*/
        grib_accessor* aa = NULL;
        if ( (a->attributes[i]->flags & GRIB_ACCESSOR_FLAG_DUMP)== 0 ) {
            ++i; /* next attribute if accessor is not for dumping */
            continue;
        }
        if ( (a->attributes[i]->flags & GRIB_ACCESSOR_FLAG_READ_ONLY)!= 0 ) {
            ++i; /* next attribute if accessor is read-only */
            continue;
        }

        aa = a->attributes[i];
        /*native_type = grib_accessor_get_native_type(aa);   TODO: read only check? */

        isLeafKey = aa->attributes[0]==NULL ? 1 : 0; /* update global variable */

        if (compare_attribute(handle1, handle2, options, aa, prefix, err)) {
            (*err)++;
            write_messages(handle1, handle2);
            ret = 1;
        }

        ++i; /* next attribute */
    }

    return ret;
}

static int compare_attribute(grib_handle* handle1, grib_handle* handle2, grib_runtime_options* options,
        grib_accessor* a, const char* prefix, int* err)
{
    int ret = 0;
    grib_context* c = handle1->context;
    char* fullname = (char*)grib_context_malloc_clear( c, sizeof(char)*(strlen(a->name)+strlen(prefix)+5) );
    sprintf(fullname, "%s->%s", prefix, a->name);
    if (compare_values(options, handle1, handle2, fullname, GRIB_TYPE_UNDEFINED)) {
        (*err)++;
        write_messages(handle1, handle2);
        ret=1;
    }
    /* Recurse if this key has children */
    if (!isLeafKey) {
        if (compare_attributes(handle1, handle2, options, a, fullname, err)) {
            ret=1;
        }
    }
    grib_context_free(c, fullname);
    return ret;
}

static int compare_all_dump_keys(grib_handle* handle1, grib_handle* handle2, grib_runtime_options* options, int *pErr)
{
    int ret=0;
    const char* name=NULL;
    grib_keys_iterator* iter  = NULL;
    grib_context* context=handle1->context;

    if (!headerMode) {
        /* See ECC-333: By setting unpack we get ALL the bufr keys. */
        /*              In headerMode we want just the header ones */
        grib_set_long(handle1,"skipExtraKeyAttributes",1); /* See ECC-745 */
        ret = grib_set_long(handle1,"unpack",1);
        if (ret != GRIB_SUCCESS) {
            grib_context_log(context, GRIB_LOG_ERROR, "Failed to unpack 1st message: %s", grib_get_error_message(ret));
            exit(1);
        }
        grib_set_long(handle2,"skipExtraKeyAttributes",1); /* See ECC-745 */
        ret = grib_set_long(handle2,"unpack",1);
        if (ret != GRIB_SUCCESS) {
            grib_context_log(context, GRIB_LOG_ERROR, "Failed to unpack 2nd message: %s", grib_get_error_message(ret));
            exit(1);
        }
    }
    iter=grib_keys_iterator_new(handle1,0,NULL);

    if (!iter) {
        grib_context_log(context, GRIB_LOG_ERROR, "unable to create keys iterator");
        exit(1);
    }

    release_keys_list(); /* The keys list is used to determine the rank */
    new_keys_list();

    while(grib_keys_iterator_next(iter))
    {
        int rank = 0;
        int dofree = 0;
        char* prefix = NULL;
        grib_accessor* xa=grib_keys_iterator_get_accessor(iter);

        isLeafKey = 0; /* clear global variable for each key */
        name=grib_keys_iterator_get_name(iter);
        if (blacklisted(name)) continue;
        if (xa==NULL || ( xa->flags & GRIB_ACCESSOR_FLAG_DUMP )==0 ) continue;

        /* Get full name of key, e.g. '#2#windSpeed' or 'blockNumber' */
        rank = compute_bufr_key_rank(handle1, keys_list, xa->name);
        if (rank != 0) {
            prefix=(char*)grib_context_malloc_clear(context,sizeof(char)*(strlen(xa->name)+10));
            dofree = 1;
            sprintf(prefix,"#%d#%s", rank, xa->name);
        } else {
            prefix = (char*)xa->name;
        }

        if (blacklisted(prefix)) continue;

        /* Compare the key itself */
        if (compare_values(options, handle1, handle2, prefix, GRIB_TYPE_UNDEFINED)) {
            (*pErr)++;
            write_messages(handle1, handle2);
            ret=1;
        }
        /* Now compare the key attributes (if any) */
        if (compare_attributes(handle1, handle2, options, xa, prefix, pErr)) {
            (*pErr)++;
            write_messages(handle1, handle2);
            ret=1;
        }
        if (dofree) grib_context_free(context, prefix);
    }

    grib_keys_iterator_delete(iter);

    /* ECC-356: Handling special case of 'ident' key */
    name = "ls.ident";
    if (!blacklisted("ident") && grib_is_defined(handle1, name) && grib_is_defined(handle2, name)) {
        if (compare_values(options, handle1, handle2, "ident", GRIB_TYPE_STRING)) {
            (*pErr)++;
            write_messages(handle1, handle2);
            ret=1;
        }
    }

    return ret;
}

static int compare_handles(grib_handle* handle1, grib_handle* handle2, grib_runtime_options* options)
{
    int err = 0;
    int i=0;
    grib_keys_iterator* iter  = NULL;
    const char* name=NULL;

    /* mask only if no -c option or headerMode (-H)*/
    if (blacklist && ( !listFromCommandLine || headerMode )) {
        /* See ECC-245, GRIB-573, GRIB-915: Do not change handles in memory */
        /*
        grib_string_list* nextb=blacklist;
        while (nextb) {
            grib_clear(handle1,nextb->value);
            grib_clear(handle2,nextb->value);
            nextb=nextb->next;
        }*/
    }

    if ( listFromCommandLine && onlyListed ) {
        for (i=0; i< options->compare_count; i++) {
            if (blacklisted((char*)options->compare[i].name)) continue;
            if (options->compare[i].type == GRIB_NAMESPACE) {
                iter=grib_keys_iterator_new(handle1,0,options->compare[i].name);
                if (!iter) {
                    grib_context_log(handle1->context, GRIB_LOG_ERROR, "unable to get iterator");
                    exit(1);
                }
                while(grib_keys_iterator_next(iter))
                {
                    name=grib_keys_iterator_get_name(iter);
                    /*printf("----- comparing %s\n",name);*/

                    if (blacklisted(name)) continue;
                    if(compare_values(options,handle1,handle2,name,GRIB_TYPE_UNDEFINED))  {
                        err++;
                        write_messages(handle1,handle2);
                    }
                }
                grib_keys_iterator_delete(iter);
            } else {
                if( compare_values(options,handle1,handle2,options->compare[i].name,options->compare[i].type))
                    err++;
                write_messages(handle1,handle2);
            }
        }
    } else {
        const void *msg1=NULL,*msg2=NULL;
        size_t size1=0,size2=0;
        int memcmp_ret=0;
        /* int ii=0; */
        GRIB_CHECK_NOLINE(grib_get_message(handle1,&msg1,&size1),0);
        GRIB_CHECK_NOLINE(grib_get_message(handle2,&msg2,&size2),0);
        if (size1==size2 && !(memcmp_ret=memcmp(msg1,msg2,size1))) {
            return 0;
        } 
#if 0
        else {
            int lcount=count,ii;
            if (options->current_infile) lcount=options->current_infile->filter_handle_count;
            if (size1 != size2) {
                printf("#%d different size: %d!=%d\n",lcount,(int)size1,(int)size2);
            }
            if (memcmp_ret) {
                unsigned char *m1=(unsigned char*)msg1;
                unsigned char *m2=(unsigned char*)msg2;
                printf("=== list of different bytes for message %d\n",lcount);
                for (ii=0;ii<size1;ii++) {
                    if (memcmp(m1,m2,1)) {
                        printf("  %d 0x%.2X != 0x%.2X\n",ii,*m1,*m2);
                    }
                    m1++; m2++;
                }
            }
            return err;
        }
#endif

        if ( listFromCommandLine ) {
            for (i=0; i< options->compare_count; i++) {
                if (blacklisted(name)) continue;
                if (options->compare[i].type == GRIB_NAMESPACE) {
                    iter=grib_keys_iterator_new(handle1,0,options->compare[i].name);
                    if (!iter) {
                        grib_context_log(handle1->context, GRIB_LOG_ERROR,
                                "ERROR: unable to get keys iterator for %s",options->compare[i].name);
                        exit(1);
                    }
                    while(grib_keys_iterator_next(iter))
                    {
                        name=grib_keys_iterator_get_name(iter);
                        /*printf("----- comparing %s\n",name);*/

                        if (blacklisted(name)) continue;
                        if(compare_values(options,handle1,handle2,name,GRIB_TYPE_UNDEFINED)) {
                            err++;
                            write_messages(handle1,handle2);
                            if (compare_all_dump_keys(handle1,handle2,options,&err)) {
                                err++;
                            }
                        }
                    }
                    grib_keys_iterator_delete(iter);
                } else {
                    if( compare_values(options,handle1,handle2,options->compare[i].name,options->compare[i].type)) {
                        err++;
                        write_messages(handle1,handle2);
                        if (compare_all_dump_keys(handle1,handle2,options,&err)) {
                            err++;
                        }
                    }
                }
            }
        } else {
            if (compare_all_dump_keys(handle1,handle2,options,&err)) {
                err++;
            }
        }

    }
    return err;
}

int grib_no_handle_action(grib_runtime_options* options, int err)
{
    fprintf(dump_file,"\t\t\"ERROR: unreadable message\"\n");
    return 0;
}